FALL 2005

Enterprise Risk Management Addresses
Wide Range of Business Exposures

Driven by a broad spectrum of risk factors—ranging from natural disasters and terrorist threats to pending legislation and supply chain interruptions—businesses of all sizes increasingly are looking to Enterprise Risk Management (ERM) to assess the potential impact of such risks on their success and their very survival.

The goal of ERM is to prevent the significant damage that can be experienced by an organization—both financial and reputational—when risk is addressed in silos, as historically has been the case, rather than managed across the enterprise.

ERM is a framework for identifying, measuring, monitoring and controlling risks in a holistic, top-down, integrated and comprehensive manner throughout an entire company. ERM is best defined by "Enterprise Risk Management – Integrated Framework," a document published last fall by the Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission (COSO). (Access the executive summary.)

According to the COSO document, ERM is:

  • A process, ongoing and flowing through an entity;
  • Effected by people at every level of an organization;
  • Applied in a strategic setting;
  • Applied across the enterprise, at every level and unit, and includes taking an entity-level portfolio view of risk;
  • Designed to identify potential events that, if they occur, will affect the entity and to manage risk within its risk appetite;
  • Able to provide reasonable assurance to an entity's management and board of directors; and
  • Geared to achievement of objectives in one or more separate but overlapping categories.

Among the tools that organizations are using to apply this approach are statistical and spreadsheet packages, treasury workstation risk modules and specialized ERM software.

Leveraging Compliance Efforts
In response to the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 (SOX), many organizations have deeply examined their internal processes and have greater responsibilities for transparency and due diligence. Their managers can leverage the information they gathered in the compliance effort to affect future strategic business decisions across the entity.

Stephen Baird, Principal at consulting firm Treasury Strategies, explains: "Companies are seeking to create a stronger process for identifying and managing risk, and making this process accountable at the senior-most level of the organization."

The ultimate goal is using "prudent business judgment with a balanced application of tools to optimize performance and shareholder value," Baird says.

According to Treasury Strategies' 2005 Corporate Treasury Management Research Program, over 20% of ERM programs reside in treasury, more than in any other function. Treasury managers, who are often tapped to lead risk management efforts, are well positioned for this expanded role. The same Treasury Strategies survey revealed that treasury managers already see benefits and value in implementing ERM, such as:

  • enhanced internal controls and SOX compliance;
  • improved ability to identify existing and newly developing risks;
  • reduced insurance premiums;
  • reduced cost of capital and/or enhanced debt capacity; and
  • an instilled culture of risk management at the business line level.

Treasury Takes Lead on Risk
"Treasurers will come into the leadership role with credibility on financial risks," says Michael Bailey, Managing Director of Protiviti, a provider of risk consulting and internal audit services. "The key is extending that credibility to other types of risks—operational, strategic and reporting."

To get started on an ERM program, begin by studying the COSO document cited above. Bailey suggests your next steps include the following:

  • Insist on senior management or board involvement.
  • Clearly define what the company wants to achieve through ERM.
  • Develop a value proposition for ERM that outlines costs and benefits, both tangible and intangible.
  • Build relationships with other areas of the company and draw them into the process.
  • Realize that most other risk types are harder to quantify; don't reflexively apply financial risk techniques to non-financial risks.
  • Integrate ERM with the core management processes and the firm's business and strategic planning activities.
  • Leverage the infrastructure created to comply with SOX.

Bailey adds that linking ERM to the existing performance measurement framework can move the organization to better strategic decision making with powerful results. "Linking ERM with leading indicators such as brand awareness and customer satisfaction, cost efficiency improvement, product innovation and others can advance the cause of ERM substantially," he says.

Measure, Quantify Investments
"Treasury has the opportunity to steer ERM away from the compliance character it has taken on at many companies toward a greater focus on optimal risk taking," Baird suggests.

Still, up-front investments in ERM, whether in software or consulting fees, must be measured and quantified against its long-term success, he says.

To that end, cutting edge companies are measuring ERM's success by quantifying the risk/reward tradeoff. Some are capturing the "near miss" adverse events and using Six Sigma to understand what potential losses could have been. Others are tracking actual loss events over time and measuring any reductions attributable to ERM.

ERM Challenges
Challenges to successful ERM implementation include insufficient time, inadequate personnel and insufficient budget, according to the recent research study, "Managing Business Risk in 2006 and Beyond," conducted by FM Global and Harris Interactive.

But when you consider that 80% of all major value losses involve the interaction of more than one risk—according to the risk consulting experts at Deloitte—companies today cannot ignore the potential of ERM to help them more smoothly navigate a volatile future.

 
View other articles in this edition

  Proactive Account Analysis Reviews
    Increase Efficiency, Reduce Costs

  SOX Subcertification Poses Personal Risks

  Have You Focused Enough on Check Quality?




ERM is a framework for identifying, measuring, monitoring and controlling
risks ... throughout an entire company.